Why Your Mutual Fund Doesn’t Return as Much as You Think
(ARA) - As tax time nears, many mutual fund investors are starting to wince. While most mutual funds’ returns were down last year, their tax bill remains high.
After years under-performing the S&P 500, the average US stock mutual fund finally beat the index last year. But while the average fund was down just 0.37% v. the S&P 500’s 9.1% drop, investors in the average fund actually lost around 3% when you add in the fees and capital gains taxes they must pay, says James O’Shaughnessy, CEO of Netfolio.com and author of the bestseller What Works on Wall Street.
“Mutual fund performance figures often leave out the taxes and some fees you are required to pay as an investor,” says O’Shaughnessy, a former mutual fund manager and architect of a new investment service that eliminates the big drawbacks of mutual funds. “The little guy is left thinking he didn’t do too badly when in fact he didn’t do nearly as well as he thought.”
Even the Securities and Exchange Commission is fed up. Just weeks ago, the SEC set new rules requiring mutual funds to disclose what they haven’t disclosed for years — the impact of income taxes on a fund’s performance.
In the 1990s, investors all but overlooked their tax hit and the hidden costs in mutual fund investing. Strong and steady bull market fund returns made taxes a non-issue. But now, as investors gear up to pay taxes in April, many are discovering the inequity of paying high taxes on funds that declined in value.
How do taxes eat into fund returns? Let’s say you invested $1,000 in the average mutual fund in January 2000. You would think that because the fund declined 0.37%, it left you with about $996 in December. Not too bad, you say, it could have been worse.
But not so fast. Throughout the year, the manager of the average mutual fund commonly sells 92% of his fund’s stocks in an attempt to boost returns. Who pays the capital gains taxes on his giddy trading activity? You do. In fact, you’ll have to pay a higher, short-term tax rate on the gains from assets the manger held for less than a year.
That means you’ll have to use your income tax bracket to calculate your bill rather than the lower 20% rate charged on long-term gains. Your tax rate on these gains could be as high as 50% after you add up the your federal, state and local tax rates.
But taxes are only half the story. The typical mutual fund also charges annual fees, an expense ratio it uses to pay the fund manager, and transaction costs it uses to pay the fund’s brokerage expenses.
Now let’s revisit that $1,000 you invested in the average mutual fund last January. By December, you would have paid about $18 in fees and about $12 in capital gains taxes. So you lost about $30 on your $1,000 investment, not $3.70. That’s about a 3% decline rather than the 0.37% drop reported recently by fund-tracking firm Lipper Inc. The 0.37% decline is the gross return of the average US stock fund and does not include taxes or fees.
“Mutual fund investors should be offended by the amount of taxes and fees they have to pay,” says O’Shaughnessy. “Mutual funds may seem like no-brainer investments but they can compromise your long-term savings potential. All the money you spend on fees and short-term capital gains taxes could have remained invested and compounding.”
O’Shaughnessy has identified five big mutual fund drawbacks:
- High expense ratios. Investors pay a fee for the privilege of owning shares. That fee goes to the fund’s manager. But instead of a flat amount, the fee is based on your assets in the fund. The more money you have invested, the higher your fee.
- Undisclosed transaction costs. This is the fee that a mutual fund pays to its broker to buy and sell stocks. The fee is not found in a fund’s prospectus and is deducted from the fund’s returns. The higher the fund’s portfolio turnover rate, the higher its transaction costs.
- No control. You have no say over what stocks the fund owns. Some stocks may be ideal for you while others are not.
- Little knowledge. Because you don’t know what specific assets a mutual fund owns on a daily basis, you could wind up owning the same stocks in several different funds. Or the types of stocks the fund buys now may differ from the ones it set out to buy when you originally invested.
- Significant tax hits. In addition to the capital gains taxes you pay when your fund manager actively trades stocks, you also face “embedded capital gains.” These can occur when a fund you recently bought sells a stock it has held for many years. Your tax hit on that trade will be equal to someone who has the same amount invested but owned the fund for many years and profited from that stock’s long run-up in price.
What’s the average mutual fund investor to do? Alternatives are emerging that provide individuals with more control over their investments and taxes. The Web-based services in this new “personal fund” sector offer stock portfolios that are tailored to an individual investor’s personal financial goals.
Instead of buying mutual fund shares, investors in personal funds buy an entire portfolio of stocks for a relatively low minimum investment. By owning the stocks in a personal fund, you control your capital gains taxes by choosing when to buy and sell stocks. You also know at all times the stocks you own.
The low cost of ownership and individual control of tax responsibilities offer individuals significant advantages over mutual funds and other popular investment vehicles. As such, Forrester Research, an e-commerce research firm in Cambridge, Mass., predicted that more than $1 trillion will be invested in personalized funds rather than mutual funds over the next 10 years.
“The days when mutual fund investors have to eat what they are served are over,” says O’Shaughnessy of Netfolio.com. “Personal funds make it possible for every individual investor to own a professionally selected stock portfolio that is reasonably priced and designed for their needs and goals.”
**********************************************************************************************
Netfolio.com is one of several new services offering individual investors personalized fund portfolios and — surprise — the first headed by a former mutual fund manager.
To begin investing at Netfolio, you pay $200 a year or $20 a month to subscribe to its service. Then you open a Bear Stearns account online at the Netfolio site at no additional cost.
To invest, you ask Netfolio to recommend personal funds that suit your investment objectives. Or you can pick them on your own from Netfolio’s list. Each personal fund comes with a recommended stock portfolio that you can customize prior to investment.
You can buy an entire portfolio of stocks in a personal fund with a minimum investment of just $5,000. And there are no commissions when you invest in Netfolio’s personal funds online through Bear Stearns.
“This type of personalized investment advice used to be available only to the superwealthy,” O’Shaughnessy says. “Now, thanks to the Internet, individual investors everywhere can access the same type of service through their computer.”
Courtesy ARA Content, www.ARAcontent.com; e-mail: info@ARAcontent.com
Previous Articles Highlighter:
Why Mobile SMSText Messaging (1)
The service need extra attention in terms of providing high service levelsThere are many independent providers of mobile data services focussed in the domain of enterprise messaging that provide end-to-end SMS/text messaging service.
Better Decisions Balancing Efficiency BuyIn (2)
Who represents the interests of affected constituencies? Ignoring these questions could come back to bite you in the implementation stage. 6. Shared Goals & Conflicts of Interest Do others share your goals?
A Mass Customization Revolution (3)
The CO2 laser market has grown on average of 60% per year. More people are recognizing the benefits of using a CO2 laser over other traditional manufacturing tools. Machinery like dies, routers, hot knives, and mechanical engravers are being replaced with affordable low wattage RFL systems.
Why PR Is An Engine For Economic Growth (4)
One of the painful aspects of the whole drill is that a PR goal without a strategy to show you how to get there, is like a three-bean salad without the beans.
Step Back To Succeed In Decision Making (5)
This trait can be learnt, but for some people it is easier to master than others. First, you must remember that all stress is a state of mind. I think I’ll repeat it, just so you get it – All stress is a state of mindIf you think that you can’t cope – you won’t.
How To Negotiate A Settlement With An Insurance Claims Adjuster By Dan Baldyga (6)
Because personal injury claims continue to pile up and clog their incoming pipeline. They’ve got a lot of other unsuspecting prey to trap and shoot and it’s clear you're an individual who’s too wise, too tough and too difficult for them to fuss with any longer.DISCLAIMER: The only purpose of this claim tip is to help people understand the motor vehicle accident claim process.
Something New For Managers (7)
Always be careful that your chosen strategy flows naturally from your public relations goal. Now, what will you say to members of that key target audience that, hopefully, will alter the inaccurate perception you discovered?
7 Work At Home Mistakes To Avoid (8)
When visiting Forums, always look for their rules/regulations , so you know what is and is not acceptable on these Forums. 4. Submitting to FFA's. These are free for all sites that you can post your ads on.
Three Proven Steps To Improve Your Home Business Advertising Response In Just 1 (9)
Newspaper advertising is a tremendous source of new business that for so many businesses doesn’t ever reach its true potential. These 3 steps will help you change that forever! You’re about to find out the mistakes that your competitors keep on making, and to start using techniques proven to grab your prospect’s attention and draw out responses that turn your ad into the 'customer producer' you always knew it should be.
This Is The Power Of PR (10)
Questions like these: how much do you know about our organization? How much do you know about our services or products and employees? Have you had prior contact with us and were you pleased with the interchange?
Working As A Knowledge Worker In The Information Age (11)
In this sort of environment, workers experience stresses such as: remembering who is in the network; knowing what people in the network are currently doing; where they are located; choices among the many forms of media means to communicate effectively with people; being mindful to 'keep in touch' with contacts who may prove useful in the near or distant future.In contrast to the personal network view, the bulk of the management literature on work place organisation reflects a team based approach.
Networking 1 (12)
As a new business owner you must wear many hats.You will need knowledge of accounting, marketing, advertising, management, administration, inventory, sales, etc., in addition to knowledge pertaining to your industry. Since you may be very proficient in some of these areas, but not in others, reading and learning about these other areas is imperative.
The 6 Stages Of Modern Career Development (13)
Casto is a whole life coach, speaker, and author of Get Smart! About Modern Romantic Relationships, Get Smart! About Modern Career Development, and Get Smart! About Modern Stress Management.
Ten Effective Ways To Reduce Your Business Costs (14)
Keep an eye out for stores that have big sales. Purchase the supplies when they go on sale before you need them.8. Used Stuff If your business equipment and supplies don't need to be new, buy them used.
Achieve More In 2 (15)
Years ago, when I chose to quit smoking, I listed 75 benefits and when I felt the urge for a cigarette I would review this list to help me get past that craving.
Time Out (16)
He has wide experience within the financial services industry, writes a weekly newsletter for Ethos Advisory Services, and coordinates the developments at Echievements. Ray holds a Masters Degree from Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary, Hamilton, MA.
Common Mistakes Motorcycle Buyers Make When Looking For A Motorcycle Loan By Jay Fran (17)
Whether interest rates are high or low or it’s the end of a model year with lots of incentives, motorcycle buyers tend to make the same mistakes when shopping for a motorcycle loan.
Surviving The Workday In Your Organization (18)
Lorraine is also a dynamic speaker and has produced many products including "How to Survive and Thrive at Work!"To subscribe to her free ezine visit www.office-organiser.com.auThis article may be reproduced providing it is published in it's entirety, including the author's bio and all links.
The Delicate Art Of Balancing The Budget (19)
One of the things which used to distinguish between political camps in the USA - Democrats versus Republicans - was their attitude towards the role of government in the economy.
Team Effort Pays Off For Entrepreneurs (20)
Coaches serve a variety of businesses and professionals from florists and printers to chiropractors and manufacturing companies. Most entrepreneurs have few resources and few places to turn to get advice on sales, marketing and team building.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
Useful Tips On Buying A New Or Used Car By John Mussi (1)
Dealers may be willing to bargain on their profit margin. Usually, this is the difference between the manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP) and the invoice price. Because the price is a factor in the dealer’s calculations regardless of whether you pay cash or finance your car — and also affects your monthly payments — negotiating the price can save you money.
Venture Leasing A Smarter Way To Build Enterprise Value (2)
Lower payments result in higher earnings and cash flow. Since a fair market value option is not an obligation, the lessee has a high degree of flexibility and control.
Using Sector Funds To Construct Diversified Mutual Fund Portfolios (3)
At the end of the day, you should be right more often than wrong with the sectors you select. AlphaProfit.com’s research suggests that by constructing diversified mutual fund portfolios using sector funds, investors have the potential to outperform the market averages on the basis of relative returns as well as risk-adjusted returns.
What Is Road Hazard Warranty? Do You Really Need It? By Gene Grant (4)
Some Road Hazrd packages provide a nationwide coverage, which are great for people who are traveling, or vacationing, because you now have peace of mind knowing that you are protected while away from your local area.
To Grow Out Of Unemployment (5)
School dropouts form a large part of the structural unemployment in many countries. In countries which are in the process of shifting from one economic system to another, even those with the right formal education are made redundant and useless by the new paradigm.
How To Take Your Stalled Projects To The Finish Line (6)
While you're in a creative mode, you're most likely to be swamped with ideas! Most people have too few ideas or too many. Here’s how to deal with the "too many to finish" challenge.(1) Stop berating yourself for not finishing a project.
Temp Gretta And The Great Seattle Race (7)
Her hands bandaged from paper cuts, her back just barely healed from heavy lifting, Gretta was determined to have that job if it was the last thing she ever did!
The Rules Of The Road By Kevin Schappell (8)
They are there as a signal to inform your fellow drivers where you plan to go. I guess this has been a list of my pet peeves, but I hope it will help you have a safer trip down the road.
Social Engineering The Real ETerrorism (9)
Put an information classification system in place to protect sensitive information. Conduct regular audits, not only on IT systems but also on policies, procedures and personnel so that any potential weaknesses can be addressed as soon as possible.Rhona Aylward has extensive experience in the area of Quality Management and more recently in Information Security Management.
Who Is Running Your Business (10)
It is as simple as changing your. Sales reminder: People naturally want what they cannot have. This applies to every sale and every referral. Think about something you once wanted and now have.
Can You Really Improve Your Organisation Skills (11)
It's only a question of changing habits, however, everything is connected. You cannot be a complete mess in your personal life and expect to be perfectly organised in your business life."So you see it doesn't matter who or what you are, anybody can learn the basic fundamental skills and experience the daily benefits of being organised.It's just a case of recognising that you need to improve in that area and as mentioned in one of the comments, you have to have the desire to change.
Want To Loosen Uncle Sam’s Grip On Your Wallet (12)
If you have losses exceeding $3,000, you can carry them forward and apply them to next year's taxes.Be Smart about Higher Education CostsThe Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 created a number of tax-advantaged ways to pay for college.
Why Choose A Bad Credit Personal Loan (13)
One of the reasons for choosing a Bad Credit Personal Loan is that it is a loan specifically designed for the many people with a bad credit rating. However created, your past record of CCJ’s (County Court Judgements), mortgage or other loan arrears can live on to deny you access to finance that other people regard as normal.
The 21st Century Way To Build Equity (14)
In other words, you'll get more value per dollar and save thousands as well; as much as 25% to 30% in interest over the life of the loan.Combine the benefits of a biweekly payment schedule with a union between an Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) mode of account servicing that is governed by Regulation "E" of the Federal Reserve to a plug into the internet and you will find a super-efficient, safe, consumer-friendly method of paying a monthly obligation that won't take a huge bite from one paycheck.
How Your Auto Insurance Rates Are Determined By A. Chris Tijerina (15)
Your auto insurance rates are determined by a number of factors: driving record usage, how you are using the vehicle, work, pleasure, business how many drivers you have and their ages how many vehicles you have what kind of coverage limits you want what area you live in your payment history what color car you drive your insurance credit score your claims history your occupation and how many years you have lived at your current residence how fast you can solve a Rubix cube your daily, weekly, annual mileage There is a lot of information about you that is used to determine your rates.
Characteristics Of High Performance Teams (16)
Traut is the president of Entelechy, Inc., a company that helps organizations unlock the potential of their people through customized training programs in the areas of sales, management, customer service, and training.
What You Must Know When Marketing Your Business (17)
What to do about it? How attractive is your product or service to the consumer?HOW DO YOU GET THERE? Target market Staff involvement Most effective strategies for marketing and selling your services/product What is your plan of action?
Yesterday’s Project Manager Is Today’s Project Engineer (18)
Younger engineers do the bulk of work and when it comes to the face value with clients and the company's brass, they are getting almost nothing. Could this be the reason why there is a higher turnaround in the companies with larger percentage of younger engineers.Ramakrishna Pochiraju is registered professional engineer.
Become A Customer EnthusiasmGuru (19)
Despite their multi-tasking titles of bookkeeper, service provider and sales-manager, their most important title is Customer-Enthusiasm Guru.Your question, undoubtedly, is how do I find time in my unbelievably over-loaded schedule to become a customer-enthusiasm guru?
How To Walk The Floor And Talk To Customers (20)
2. Overcoming Embarrassment Many owners will not walk the floor and talk to customers because they get embarrassed starting a conversation. If this applies to you, then take out a sample of products and ask customers to try them.
Permalink to Why Your Mutual Fund Doesn’t Return as Much as You Think