Working as a Knowledge Worker in the Information Age
The old adages: “It’s not what you know, but who you know” and “High Tech, High Touch” could be the mottos of knowledge workers in the 21st Century.
Never before in the history of the world has both networking and interpersonal communication been potentially easier, broader, more wide-spread and paradoxically, more difficult.
The access to people and information in the information age is without parallel in history. The same technology which has enabled this to happen, has also reduced the time between communications from weeks to seconds.
There is simply no officially available time within which to conduct the communications on which networking and interpersonal contacts depend. The time that people used to spend thinking and crafting their communications and interacting is now at a premium. While the volume of communications has expanded exponentially so too has, what I can only refer to as ‘noise’. Noise, being communications whose content is usually less than useful and in many nstances banal and not useful at all.
Most of what appears in the journals, in public forums and in discussions describes new forms of work place organisation that assume solid support from the institution in which they form.
Coherent groups which used to be called “self interest” groups and are now re-badged and called “communities of interest” or “expert groups” or ‘learning communities” or ‘quality circles” or “virtual teams” or “communities of practice”.
Groups which do receive official encouragement and institutional support are usually not only unsuccessful, but in many instances, actively resented by the participants who are often “selected” by their senior management colleagues to attend.
The resentment appears to be based on the fact that the individual has not self selected the people with whom he/she would like to communicate, this choice is made for him/her by management. Generally there is:
- no assessment about whether the person is the ‘right person’ for the discussion and/or topic under discussion;
- no attempt to undertake any ice breaker exercises when the groups first meet to try and ensure that there is a sufficient and necessary breakdown of the interpersonal barriers to communication; and
- no attempt to realise or rationalise the differing political agendas that each individual has been sent to present to the meeting by his/her administrative supervisor.
The means by which these groups are set up and managed, presents a barrier to its success. This is generally not acknowledged by the management that keeps on setting up these groups, usually because they have read a little in the literature and skimmed the information, found a good idea and then without in depth knowledge about what they are doing, launched their next management ‘fad’.
It is interesting to observe, by way of contrast, that those groups that self create and self moderate and do NOT include the management layer at all within their constructs, seem to do very well and achieve a lot. There is however a downside which is a period during which the original purpose of the gathering has been achieved and the group struggles to find a new ‘raison d’étre’ to continue because they value the interactions, the mutual upports and the ‘tick tacking’ discussions which add value to each person’s understanding by leveraging the understanding and/or perceptions of the others in the group. Most often than not, this fails and the group engages in a process that is like ’swirling’. It disbands, members keep their contacts alive and when a new reason for meeting emerges then some of the original group reforms involving others in the group as their interests and/or expertise comes to bear.
The work which actually takes place behind the scenes to maintain contact and to keep supporting each other is intensive, hidden and generally not reported in any way within existing reporting structures or performance reporting tools. It can take up at least 1/3 of a working day. How it is factored into information lodged within tool suites that attempt to record work to funded projects is one of the most well kept secrets used by most staff.
The reports that these groups make to management, with their usually innovative and practical suggestions are probably the best form of intelligence the organisation could harvest. There is unfortunately serious resistance from the senior management layer to receiving and considering the information, because it is perceived as having come from what are described as ‘feral’ groups within the organisation. Cynics in the work place usually ascribe this reaction to senior managers being miffed that they cannot claim kudos from the work because they did not even know it was happening.There are companies around the world who reward and indeed fund ‘feral’ behaviour. One company for example has created the ‘thief of the year’ award. It is given the person who can find something in the public domain which he/she then leverages to substantially improve the corporate bottom line. The same company also funds its staff to go off line and develop a productive idea at full pay for a period of six months. If they succeed then they are rewarded and the company gets the benefit of their work. If they fail then they are sacked or at minimum placed into work situations where their independence is considerably constrained for an extended period. This usually puts the intrapreneur on his her mettle and forces a risk management approach to the innovation cycle before choosing to try out that idea and increases the pressure to succeed once the choice has been made.
The reality for most workers is that the many manifestations of organisational change - downsizing, outsourcing, merging, splitting, acquiring, partnering, and the constant redrawing of internal boundaries, responsibilities and organisational charts leads to situations in which it is increasingly difficult for workers to turn to established role based structures in their organisations when they need labour or information. It is in these conditions that workers leverage their own personal networks rather than relying on unstable and weakening organisation charts. Workers are empowered only if they are successful at creating and maintaining their own personal social networks. The work of networking really is ‘invisible work’ which is not accounted for in workflow diagrams or performance evaluations.
In the past, employees worked for relatively long periods in ‘communities of practice’ (Wenger, 1988) within which they built up expertise in the details of their jobs. “Research on communities of practice has documented a number of important characteristics of this style of work: workers operated within clearly defined organizational and social roles, they were highly familiar with one another and shared considerable social, cultural and organizational knowledge that served as a backdrop for work and interaction. Workers were generally, (but not always) co-located, making it possible to have frequent interpersonal communications that contributed to the creation of shared knowledge, and facilitated the smooth execution of work tasks.” (Kraut et al., 1993; Whittaker et al., 1994; Nardi and Engeström, 1999) - Quoted in “It’s Not What You Know, It’s Who You Know: Work in the Information Age.” Nardi, Bonnie A.; Whittaker, Steve; Schwarz, Heinrich 2001 www.firstmonday.dk
Recent management literature has documented that these working conditions are rapidly becoming obsolete. One of the consequences of these organisational and technical changes is that in many companies and organisations operations are conducted in an increasingly ‘distributed’ manner - i.e. where the workers, contractors, consultants, and important contacts can be distributed across the organisation and indeed the world. In this sort of environment, workers experience stresses such as:
- remembering who is in the network;
- knowing what people in the network are currently doing;
- where they are located;
- choices among the many forms of media means to communicate effectively with people;
- being mindful to ‘keep in touch’ with contacts who may prove useful in the near or distant future.
In contrast to the personal network view, the bulk of the management literature on work place organisation reflects a team based approach. This literature generically seems to assume that workers go about their business in teams with clearly defined and stable roles, functions and responsibilities. In much the same way, there is a further assumption that organisations have predictable, stable structures.
In listening to people in at least one large Commonwealth organisation both of these assumptions are invalid. Other researchers report similar viewpoints in many other bureaucracies, for example: Fisher and Fisher, 1998; Lloyd and Boyle 1998, Jarvenapaa and Leidner, 1999, Mark, Grudin and Poltrock, 1999.
In this brief overview what is being suggested is that management groups re-appraise their directions and consider whether their official structures are delivering the outcomes which were predicted and/or imagined and then explore whether the vitality of unleashing and supporting underground, feral or more ‘neural’ networks offer a better direction.
Bibliography:
D. Ancona and D. Caldwell , 1988. “Beyond Task and Maintenance,” Group and Organizational Studies, Volume 13, number 4, pp. 468-494.
L. Bishop, 1999. “Visible and Invisible Work: The Emerging Post-Industrial Employment Relation,” In: B. Nardi and Y. Engeström (guest editors). Computer Supported Cooperative Work, Volume 8, numbers 1-2 (special issue), pp. 115-126.
Y. Engeströrn and V. Escalante, 1996. “Mundane Tool or Object of Affection?: The Rise and Fall of the Postal Buddy,” In: B. Nardi (editor). Context and Consciousness: Activity Theory and Human - Computer Interaction. Cambridge , Mass. : MIT Press, pp. 325 -373.
A. Epstein, 1961. “The Network and Urban Social Organization,” Rhodes - Livingstone Journal, Volume 29, pp. 29-62.
K. Fisher and M. Fisher, 1998. “The Distributed Mind: Achieving High Performance though the Collective Intelligence of Knowledge Work Teams.” New York : American Management Association.
N. Friedkin, 1982. “Information Flow through Strong and Weak Ties in Intra-organizational Social Networks,” Social Networks, Volume 3, pp. 273-285.S.
Jarvenpaa and D. Leidner, 1998. “Communication and Trust in Global Virtual Teams,” Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, Volume 3, number 4 (June).
J. Lave and E. Wenger, 1991. “Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation.” Cambridge , Eng : Cambridge University Press.
P. Lloyd and P. Boyle (editors), 1998. “Web-Weaving: Intranets, Extranets, Strategic Alliances.” Oxford , Eng. : Butterworth-Heineman.
G. Mark, J. Grudin, and S. Poltrock, 1999. “Virtually Collocated Teams in the Workplace,” Proceedings, ECSCW ‘99 (6th European Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work, 12- 16 September 1999 , Copenhagen ), pp. 159-178, and at http://www.research.microsoft.com/research/coet/VirtualTeams/ECSCW99/paper.doc
B. Nardi, A. Kuchinsky, S. Whittaker, R. Leichner, and H. Schwarz, 1996. “Video-as-Data: Technical and Social Aspects of a Collaborative Multimedia Application,” Computer Supported Cooperative Work, Volume 4, number 1, PP. 73-100.
B. Nardi, and Y. Engeström, 1999. “A Web on the Wind: The Structure of Invisible Work,” In: B. Nardi and Y. Engeström (guest editors). Computer Supported Cooperative work, volume 8, numbers 1—2 (special issue), at http://www.best.com/~nardi/InvisibleW.html
E. Wenger, 1998. “Communities of Practice”. Cambridge , Eng. : Cambridge University Press.
S. Whittaker and H. Schwarz, 1999. “Meetings of the Board: The Impact of Scheduling Medium on Long Term Group Coordination in Software Development,” Computer Supported Cooperative Work, Volume 8,pp. 175-205.
L. Wildeman, 1998. “Alliances and Networks: The Next Generation,” International Journal of Technology Management, Volume 15, numbers 1/2, pp. 96-108.
A. Wolfe, 1978. “The Rise of Network Thinking in Anthropology,” Social Networks, Volume 1, pp. 53-64.
Peter Garas, B.A, B.Soc Stud, MSW has been involved in the management of social workers, IT, Knowledge Management, Information Management and Records Management in Australia since 1975.
Previous Articles Highlighter:
Networking 1 (1)
Many times the back of publications list networking and support groups. Many of the national organizations have local chapters, so the fees are fairly low, and you are becoming part of a nationwide organization, which, if they are flexible, gives you a variety of individuals to contact.
The 6 Stages Of Modern Career Development (2)
Learning the characteristics of each stage will empower you to navigate through each stage easily and with more confidence. In the Assessment Stage, you are getting ready for your life’s work.
Ten Effective Ways To Reduce Your Business Costs (3)
You can find used items at yard and garage sales, used stores, used stuff for sale message boards and newsgroups etc.9. Negotiate You should always try negotiate a lower price for any business equipment or supplies.
Achieve More In 2 (4)
If you plan to quit smoking repeat statement such as, “I enjoy the lifestyle of a non-smoker,” “I’m glad I’m a non-smoker,” “I enjoy the taste of food more as a non-smoker.” Stating affirmations aloud, reinforces your goal to your mind and will help you achieve your goal much faster.Take action.
Time Out (5)
He has wide experience within the financial services industry, writes a weekly newsletter for Ethos Advisory Services, and coordinates the developments at Echievements. Ray holds a Masters Degree from Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary, Hamilton, MA.
Common Mistakes Motorcycle Buyers Make When Looking For A Motorcycle Loan By Jay Fran (6)
How long is the term on the motorcycle loan? If the loan is an installment loan, does it use rule of 78 or simple interest? (Simple interest is always better because it does not penalize the motorcycle buyer if the loan is paid off early.) What is the down payment requirement to get the motorcycle loan?
Surviving The Workday In Your Organization (7)
And the crazy thing is, it doesn't take a lot of time and money to get in control of your life!You and Your TeamA dynamic and cohesive team in every organisation is its most valuable asset!
The Delicate Art Of Balancing The Budget (8)
This is why additional or supplementary budgets are introduced by governments during the fiscal year. These are updated versions of the original budget. They reflect the changed reality better than the outdated original.
Team Effort Pays Off For Entrepreneurs (9)
Through mentoring and advice, coaches help business owners succeed more and work less. Coaches serve a variety of businesses and professionals from florists and printers to chiropractors and manufacturing companies.
Making The Dealer An Offer By Kevin Schappell (10)
How much over invoice should you offer? 4% - 6% has been a good number. I would offer 4% over invoice if you trust the dealerships service department and plan on getting your car serviced there.
Classified Ads What Works What Doesnt (11)
A courtesy copy of your publication would be appreciated - send to: diana@ohiohelp.netDiana Barnum, president of http://movingaheadcommunications.com and CEO of http://ohiohelp.net. For more help with marketing, public relations and writing, email diana@ohiohelp.net or call: (614) 529-9459.
Choosing The Best Life Insurance Option For You (12)
The policy is also taken over a fixed term, which is where the ‘term’ part of the policy comes in. This means that you can enjoy easy budgeting and low cost repayments, and you’ll know exactly how long you will be making payment for.
How To Use Humor To Increase Sales (13)
One of the best sources is the Cartoon Bank, www.cartoonbank.com. Here, you can license reproduction rights to cartoons that originally appeared in the New Yorker Magazine.You can select from tens of thousands of cartoons.
Are You An Expert At What You Do (14)
There are students at different levels of study. For every level, there is a teacher needed. Don’t stay quiet, thinking you have nothing to offer because someone else has more.
What To Do When Your IT Project Is Late Over Budget And Looks Like Its Never Going To Work (15)
Do they know exactly what’s expected of them or have you assumed they know? Do they communicate well with each other? With users? With other departments?SOLUTION: Identify communication breakdowns now.
Naming Names How To Name Your Business Product Or Service (16)
a few minutes pass by... a few more minutes pass by• "Slice-A-Day.com" ...sidenote: visual images of pie and cake...sidenote: slice is a portion of a bigger piece...hmm• "Share Your Slice On Marketing" ...sidenote: tagline that explains and supports vision::: End Brainstorming List :::I like "slice" because you just get quick and small chunks to read...
Choosing A Merchant Account (17)
1.49%, $.30 a transaction x 10 transactions of $200 each = $32.80 1.59%, $.20 a transaction x 10 transactions of $200 each = $33.80 1.69%, $.10 a transaction x 10 transactions of $200 each = $34.80As you comparison shop please use our Merchant Account Rate Calculator to help you.http://www.121merchantaccount.com/tutorial/calculator.htm B) Bank Statements.The bank statement is a paper print out of your monthly activity.
Be A Storyteller Not Just A Speaker (18)
This will strengthen the connection between you and them. It’s a good idea to use props to enhance your humor. Remember most people have an attention span of six to eight minutes.
Troubled Waters Require Capable Leaders At The Helm (19)
Reactive flurry kills profits faster than any big external threat!Striving to improve our own competitiveness by providing customers faster and better products or services will accomplish more than worrying about the next global crisis looming just around the corner.
Successful Offshore Call Center Outsourcing (20)
HOW TO MAKE OUTSOURCING WORK FOR YOUThere is much hype about the growth of outsourcing. There are an increasing number of success stories but the number of failed projects is also on the rise.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
This Is The Power Of PR (1)
How much do you know about our services or products and employees? Have you had prior contact with us and were you pleased with the interchange? Have you experienced problems with our people or procedures?
Three Proven Steps To Improve Your Home Business Advertising Response In Just 1 (2)
Not really. OK, they hope you might, but that’s not what they intend. They are paying to have you see their message so many times that when you are ready to buy their product you will remember them and go there.
7 Work At Home Mistakes To Avoid (3)
Look at it this way , say you sign up someone under you , and they need help getting started , how are you going to help them if you do not even know this?
Something New For Managers (4)
And a strong indication that a workable department or division public relations blueprint can help a unit manager achieve his or her operating objectives. endBob Kelly counsels, writes and speaks to business, non-profit and association managers about using the fundamental premise of public relations to achieve their operating objectives.
How To Negotiate A Settlement With An Insurance Claims Adjuster By Dan Baldyga (5)
Then he’ll surely try this one on for size: “My doctor is a professional .The only people he ever sees are those who’ve been in motor vehicle accidents. That’s what he does all day long, check out personal injury claims like yours.
Step Back To Succeed In Decision Making (6)
First, you must remember that all stress is a state of mind. I think I’ll repeat it, just so you get it – All stress is a state of mindIf you think that you can’t cope – you won’t.
Why PR Is An Engine For Economic Growth (7)
In that way, those same business, non-profit and association managers can see results such as new proposals for strategic alliances and joint ventures; customers making repeat purchases; prospects starting to work with them; membership applications on the rise; capital givers or specifying sources looking their way, and even bounces in showroom visits.
A Mass Customization Revolution (8)
Machinery like dies, routers, hot knives, and mechanical engravers are being replaced with affordable low wattage RFL systems. Ink jet printers, in some applications, are losing ground to the advancing low wattage laser used for marking.What does this mean?In what other business can you invest in a piece of equipment to produce such a variety of different products?
Better Decisions Balancing Efficiency BuyIn (9)
Shared Goals & Conflicts of Interest Do others share your goals? Would they make decisions consistent with your goals for the organization? Do others have interests that conflict with the interests of the organization?
Why Mobile SMSText Messaging (10)
The prime reasons for this are: Enterprise messaging involves complex integration with backend database/applications The volume of messages is typically not high (except in large B2C companies) The criticality of message delivery is extremely high Operators largely cross subsidise ‘voice’ with ‘data’ services. It a specific network is down, then the service suffers.
Why Your Mutual Fund Doesn’t Return As Much As You Think (11)
the S&P 500's 9.1% drop, investors in the average fund actually lost around 3% when you add in the fees and capital gains taxes they must pay, says James O'Shaughnessy, CEO of Netfolio.com and author of the bestseller What Works on Wall Street."Mutual fund performance figures often leave out the taxes and some fees you are required to pay as an investor," says O'Shaughnessy, a former mutual fund manager and architect of a new investment service that eliminates the big drawbacks of mutual funds.
Useful Tips On Buying A New Or Used Car By John Mussi (12)
It frees up the equity in your home for you to use on whatever you want. You may freely reprint this information on your website provided the following caption remains intact.
Venture Leasing A Smarter Way To Build Enterprise Value (13)
First, venture leases are usually only secured by the underlying equipment. Additionally, there are usually no restrictive financial covenants. Most banks, if they lend to early stage companies, require blanket liens on all of the companies' assets.
Using Sector Funds To Construct Diversified Mutual Fund Portfolios (14)
Key Points to Remember1. Sector funds are investment vehicles that focus their investments on a particular sector or industry group. Sector funds provide investors with an opportunity to profit from trends impacting a particular sector or industry while reducing company-specific risks.2.
What Is Road Hazard Warranty? Do You Really Need It? By Gene Grant (15)
(This is called pro-rated).Here is an example. Let's say your tire is 1/2 way worn at the time of the flat. With tires averaging $100 each, your replacement cost would only be $50.00.
To Grow Out Of Unemployment (16)
It is the inevitable result of a few processes: Labour Mobility – People move from one job to another, either because they are fired or because they seek to improve their lot.
How To Take Your Stalled Projects To The Finish Line (17)
However, others (including most gifted adults) are multi-taskers, who aren't happy unless they're juggling several balls in the air.(5) Study the market for each project you are considering. Once you've identified your target customers and the need you'll be meeting -- and made sure people will pay for what you offer -- you'll realize whether moving forward makes sense.(6) File each new idea in a computer or paper folder or set up an "idea board" near your desk.
Temp Gretta And The Great Seattle Race (18)
In the dead of night they gathered, this gang for sly and sneaky temps, to fight for the longest and best temporary employee assignment in Seattle. Make no mistake about it, they would fight to the death if need be, and the losers had already pledged to turn the job down.
The Rules Of The Road By Kevin Schappell (19)
Keep that in mind the next time you squeeze in front of a truck at the stop light. Also, heavy trucks while on the highway will slow down while going up large hills but pick up speed on the downhill side.
Social Engineering The Real ETerrorism (20)
Make sure that all staff, especially non-IT staff, are aware of the risk of social engineering and what to do in the event of such an attack. Conduct regular security awareness training so that all staff are kept up to date with security related issues.
Permalink to Working as a Knowledge Worker in the Information Age